Be A Heart Gift Guide for Toddlers

Gift Guide for Toddlers: Faith-Filled Gifts They’ll Love

Finding meaningful Christian gifts for toddlers can be a challenge—parents want items that are fun, practical, durable, and rooted in faith. Whether you're shopping for birthdays, Christmas, Easter baskets, baptisms, or everyday moments, this toddler gift guide is full of beautiful, faith-centered ideas that help little ones grow in love, joy, and devotion. These Christian toddler gifts make it easy to weave simple reminders of God’s presence into daily routines.

Toddlers learn best through play, repetition, and hands-on experiences, which makes this age the perfect time to introduce simple, tangible reminders of Jesus, Mary, and the stories of our faith. This guide features our most-loved Catholic gifts for toddlers, all designed with little hands, big imaginations, and growing hearts in mind. From faith-inspired mealtime essentials to durable toys and cuddly dolls, these gifts help families incorporate moments of prayer, peace, and joy throughout the day.

1. Jesus Heals Bandages®

Turn everyday bumps and scrapes into moments of comfort and spiritual reflection with our bestselling Jesus Heals Bandages®—a toddler favorite and a wonderful addition to any Christian home.

SHOP

2. Jesus Reusable Snack Bags

Snack time gets a joyful upgrade with our Jesus Reusable Snack Bags, a favorite among parents looking for eco-friendly, faith-centered toddler gifts. These bags keep snacks fresh while reducing single-use plastics—ideal for school lunches, diaper bags, or on-the-go snacking.

Each bag features cheerful, faith-filled designs that remind little ones of Jesus’ love during even the simplest daily moments.

SHOP

3. Kids Baby Jesus Christmas Long John Pajamas & Baby Rompers

Celebrate the beauty of the season with our Baby Jesus Christmas Pajamas—a cozy and meaningful way for toddlers to enter into Advent and Christmas. These faith-filled pajamas feature a hand-illustrated nativity-inspired pattern showcasing angels, baby Jesus, the Holy Spirit, and banners reading “Glory” and “Rejoice.”

Children’s Set (2T+): Includes long-sleeve top and matching pants.

SHOP

4. Jesus Baby Doll

The Jesus Baby Doll invites toddlers into the beauty of the Nativity story with gentleness and love. Perfectly sized for small hands, this soft, cuddly doll encourages imaginative play rooted in faith.

Wrapped in soft cotton muslin and wearing a cotton diaper embroidered with the ancient Chi-Rho symbol, this baby Jesus doll becomes a tender companion throughout Advent, Christmas, and beyond.

“He was wrapped in swaddling clothes…” — Luke 2:7

SHOP

5. Good Shepherd Wooden Puzzle

Our Good Shepherd Wooden Puzzle is a beautiful way to help toddlers learn through touch, play, and repetition. The Good Shepherd symbolizes Jesus’ loving care for each of us—an easy and meaningful truth to introduce to young children.

Each poplar-wood puzzle includes extra-thick pieces that can stand on their own, transforming playtime into a hands-on faith experience.

SHOP

6. Jesus & Mary Stainless Steel Water Bottles

Jesus Water Bottle – 13.5oz Stainless Steel

Keep faith close in everyday moments with our thoughtfully designed Jesus and Mary Water Bottles—a practical essential and a beautiful Christian gift for toddlers. Created by a mom with children in mind, this 13.5oz stainless steel bottle blends durability with meaningful spiritual reminders throughout the day.

SHOP

7. Mary Doll

Soft, beautiful, and filled with meaning, our Mary Doll introduces toddlers to Our Blessed Mother in a gentle, approachable way. Available in four skin tones—reflecting how Mary has appeared across cultures—she makes faith more accessible and relatable for little ones.